Hidden Charges in MSME Bank Loans: The True Cost of Business Borrowing

Hidden Charges in MSME Bank Loans That Are Eating Your Profit Without You Knowing

Hidden Charges in MSME Bank Loans That Are Eating Your Profit Without You Knowing Read More »

Hidden Charges in MSME Bank Loans The Loan You Got Is Not the Loan You Signed Up For As part of the process, thousands of MSME entrepreneurs in India each year look into business concepts, secure fundings and approach banks for borrowing, only to realize months later that the amount they had to pay for the loan was far more than the interest rate quoted. Sanction letters with embedded processing fees. Embedded processing fees in sanction letters. Buried in a 40-page agreement, clause 18 contained pre-payment penalties. No single conversation required for insurance premiums to be bundled. These are not simple errors. They are the inherent characteristics of business lending in India — and not many MSME founders can identify them. It’s not just a financial disaster. It is informational. When a small manufacturing or trading business is run by a first-generation entrepreneur, it is highly unlikely that he/she will have a CFO to read the loan papers line by line. They are going to trust the relationship manager. What the relationship manager will likely not mention is the true cost of a loan — post all the fine print. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) mandates banks to show the Annual Percentage Rate (APR) of loans (which includes all charges). But there is limited adherence to this disclosure standard, and even the majority of borrowers are not educated on how to read and understand APR data. It leads to a systematic mismatch between what MSMEs believe they’re paying, and what they actually are. Why MSME Borrowing Is a High-Stakes Game MSME is the backbone of India’s economy. The Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises estimates that it contributes almost 30% of the GDP and employs more than 11 crore people. The demand for credit in the sector is enormous – and expanding. However, the average MSME borrower is still not well educated financially, and is especially sensitive to the types of loans that yield the highest profits for the lender. Consider the math. A manufacturing MSME takes loan of ₹50 lakh at a nominal interest rate of 11% per annum. The interest that has to be paid annually is ₹5.5 lakh on paper. However, once you factor in the processing fee (1.5%), the bundled insurance (1.2% per annum), documentation charges (₹15,000) and penal interest incurred during a cash crunch of two months, the annual cost is easily more than 16% to 18%. That’s a huge amount. And it eats into the razor-thin profit margins most MSMEs have. Thus, it’s not a financial literacy exercise to just understand these hidden charges. It’s a must learn skill for every MSME founder in the competitive environments of today. Related Article: DPR for Bank Loan: Format, Example & Step-by-Step Guide for MSME Loan Approval What the Regulatory Framework Says — And Where It Falls Short The RBI’s Fair Practices Code for Lenders says that banks and NBFCs must clearly and simply write down all charges related to their loan in the first place. Further, the MSME Samadhaan platform enables MSMEs to lodge any complaints related to payment. But disclosures of pre-disbursement charges are not enforced very well. There has been some progress made by the government. Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana (PMMY) is an initiative by the government to provide collateral-free loans. There are three schemes namely Shishu, Kishore, and Tarun with comparatively transparent fee structures. The Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) scheme minimizes the requirement for collateral and to a certain degree, insurance bundling. But, none of these schemes has gone to the extent of resolving the issue of undisclosed charges in conventional term loans and working capital facilities provided by the commercial banks. It is also worth noting that the DPIIT has created a Startup India portal with grievance redressal and financial advisory tools for the benefit of the startup entrepreneurs to help them better understand lender disclosures. Furthermore, the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) has been highlighting hidden lending charges as a structural impediment in expanding the MSME growth in India. The Major Hidden Charges That Are Costing MSMEs Dearly 1. Processing Fee: The First Hidden Blow Most founders know of the processing fee, but very few realize just how big it can be. This fee will be deducted from the sanctioned loan amount and is generally 0.5% to 2% of the sanctioned amount. If you apply for a loan of ₹50 lakh, and the processing fee is 1.5%, you’ll receive ₹49.25 lakh, but you’ll be charged interest on the entire amount of ₹50 lakh. It’s a structural feature that results in your effective interest rate starting higher than what it purports to be on the first day. 3. Prepayment and Foreclosure Penalties: The Exit Tax This is where most of the MSMEs really get taken aback. During a boom time, once the business gets better and cash flows are available, the natural inclination is to settle the loan before the time, which helps in reducing interest payments. But a lot of bank loans are subject to prepayment penalties of anything from 2 per cent to 4 per cent of the outstanding principal. A few lenders may have a lock-in requirement of 12 to 24 months, meaning you can’t make a single payment at all. This is effectively locking a borrower in to a high-cost loan when they are able to pay it off. This means that the actual price of borrowing is more expensive than any apparent interest rate comparison might indicate. Your investment deserves the right opportunity 3. Bundled Loan Insurance: The Silent Premium This is probably the most obscure of all the hidden fees. Credit life insurance or loan protection insurance is offered by many banks, especially public sector banks, as a part of the loan disbursement process. This is the premium which is levied on the loan at the rate of 0.5% to 1.5% per annum either as a lump sum or as an additional payment